Saturday, October 19, 2013

Feeding the Fire

By Judy Pilat

For this week’s blog, the question is how to pray.  Shall we pray to God’s Presence, opening ourselves to the infilling of Spirit? Or, shall we center on spirit within, allowing it to emerge? Dr. Tom Shepherd calls this the “Let It In/Let It Out” controversy.

The Let it Out position is supported by George Fox who founded the Quaker movement and theologian, Meister Eckhart, founder of German mysticism.  It is also supported by Unity’s basic principles.  According to Connie Fillmore and more recently, Ellen Debenport in her book “The Five Principles”, Unity’s second principle states that human beings have a spark of divinity within them.  Theologically speaking, this is the belief that God is immanent – within us, energizing us, inspiring us, nudging us toward our greater good.  In more traditional belief systems based on the bible and its post-Jesus interpretation, God and the Holy Spirit exist somewhere outside of our experience.  One or both may enter into the human heart and soul in response to the appropriate beliefs and/or practices.  In this system, God is transcendent.

Current Christian theology views God as both immanent and transcendent, terms that are usually viewed as contrasting propositions.  However, this is God we are talking about here.  There is no greater topic, there is no greater lesson, and perhaps logic and the traditional rules of discourse will only take us so far.  As theological thinking has evolved, so to has a middle ground or middle path that includes and reconciles our increasing body of knowledge, specifically scientific knowledge.

If God is viewed as the ground of being, the intelligent energy from which the material world is created, than God is outside of us, (or underneath us, behind us, the stuff from which we are made).  Dr. Shepherd says “Think Star Trek!  Think holodeck!” and this might cause a shift away from the “Let It Out” position towards the “Let It In” camp.   Before you actually move your chair though, consider this:  If you are growing stuff on one acre of land and you want a more bountiful harvest, you can go out and get more land, or you can concentrate on optimizing the growing conditions for the plants and trees on the acre you have.  Expand your resources without expending them as Eric Butterworth would say.  

It is possible to work with that spark of divinity to increase the light of God within, to feed the fire so to speak.   As that light grows, God moves in, through, and as us.  Humans are the hands and feet of the immanent God.  You can also acknowledge and appreciate that every other person, every living thing is likewise endowed with that divine spark within.


According to our text, “Glimpses of Truth” the Sahakains argue that God has an identity that exists independently from that immanent spark within us.  The God that is the source of the universe and the God within which the universe exists retains a distinct identity, and according to process theology, this identity is evolving.

At the end of the day, my position is that all of this is possible, and in all probability, is likely.  And at the end of the day (and the beginning too), when I pray, I center on spirit within.


Saturday, October 12, 2013

Where Does the Bible Fit?

"We know there are troubles of more than one kind.

Some come from ahead, and some come from behind. . .



The Bible is just one of many things in my “spiritual toolkit”.  When I think back to all of the sources I have used for research and quotations for classes, small groups and Sunday talks, the list includes  scripture, Dr. Seuss, Gene Rodenberry and Abraham Lincoln as well as all of the usual suspects within Unity ( Myrtle and Charles, Cady, Butterworth and Debenport, et al.)  For me, the Bible is important and relevant, but so are many other sources.  For me, spiritual understanding comes from many different sources and is inspired by the work and lives of many people who have graced the planet in the last 2,000 years as well as those who lived before Jesus.

For those who hold the bible in higher or singular regard, I want to borrow the logic of Unity’s Fifth Principal (it is not enough to know the truth, one must also live the truth) and argue that it is not enough for Christians to be saved or born again; accepting Christ is just the first step of a journey that continues for a lifetime.  Just to establish that I am not swaying precariously in the breeze, out on the edge of some New Thought limb or branch, in an earlier post, I referred to the UMC Theology of Discipleship which calls for Christians to be active participants in God’s activity in the world, living out of an understanding of who they are in relationship to God, to one another, and to the world.

I would like to suggest that in working to accomplish this, many Christians are guided and motivated by words and ideas that may be inspired by the Bible, but nonetheless have come from a whole host of human beings other than Moses, Isaiah, Matthew, Mark, Luke and John (or the scribes and authors who wrote in their names.).  The success of Joel Osteen, Rick Warren, and Billy Graham as well as more than a dozen best-selling novels in the left behind series are just a few examples of the voices that speak to and lift up (or smack down) the minds and hearts of contemporary Christians – and just FYI – there are three satellite radio stations dedicated to Christian music on Sirius XM radio alone.  Their toolkit looks different than my toolkit, but the point is that there is more than one tool in it.

This brings me then to the fundamentalists, the folks whose toolkit is not really a kit at all.  What they have, first and foremost, is the bible as the inerrant word of God, and a short list of non-negotiable beliefs that must be adhered to absolutely if one wants to be considered a “true” Christian.  According to Harvey Cox in his book “The Future of Faith”, the inerrancy of the Bible is foundational, and there are four cornerstones upon which the house of Christian American fundamentalism is built:  the Virgin birth of Christ, substitutionary atonement, bodily resurrection, and the imminent second coming.  Nothing here about discipleship, or living the truth – this is strictly a litmus test to determine if you are with us or against us.

I suppose you could think of it as a tape measure, which many consider to be a “must have” for any basic toolkit.  As you build things or make repairs and improvements, you need to make measurements to determine how things will fit together, or if they will fit at all.  However, if the only thing you have in your toolkit is a tape measure and the only thing you can do is make assessments about what fits and what doesn’t, you lack the essential tools that are needed to actually build something that works.

In working with a congregation to help them build lives that work, the more tools you have in your toolkit, the higher the probability of helping them to make some repairs or improvements that will add value and increase their equity.  However, please note that there will always be those who may flinch a bit or stiffen at the sight of the tape measure because of their previous experience with a contractor who took their money, took some measurements and never delivered anything of value except a judgment about the poor quality of the house they were living in.

I can’t erase that experience from their memory, but I can show them some plans and designs that might help them get from where they are to where they want to be, and I can share with them the tools that I have found to be helpful along the way. 

The Bible is just one of the tools in my toolkit, but there are many, many more – and I am shopping all the time!  You never know what you’re going to need to build the house of your dreams.  



Friday, October 4, 2013

One Size Will Never Fit All


The previous generation in my family stayed a lot closer to home.  The extent of their wanderings might be to marry someone who belonged to a different parish.  My parents and my aunts and uncles all married someone who was Catholic and set up their households within about 25 miles of where my grandparents lived in the city of Detroit.  The next generation, not so much.  We’ve planted ourselves in Texas and Florida, all over the state of Michigan and across the border into the Buckeye state of Ohio.

 Looking at my generation of “boomers” and beyond to Generation X,  and Generation  “wi-fi” I can clearly see a number of challenges to creating church services that satisfy this broad array of interests, experiences, and orientations.  Add to that the demographics of small “c” catholics, small “r” reformers, and small “e” evangelicals, and now you have yourself a smorgasbord of congregant criteria that is further influenced by the road they travelled to arrive at the seat they are in.  Are they a refugee, an emigrant, or a home-grown native?

I count myself in the emigrant camp.  My Catholic upbringing was not particularly intolerable and certainly not oppressive.  I just knew there was something better out there.  I did not actively seek alternatives by visiting other churches or pro-actively engaging those from other faiths.  I did, however, keep my eyes open for people who seemed to be living a life that worked, those that I would now call pragmatically  enlightened.

What I found was a handful of colleagues and acquaintances who were gracious and equitable in their dealings with others; effective and successful in their work; happy in their relationships; prosperous in their attitudes and actions; balanced and centered in their daily lives.  I observed them over time, talked with them on numerous occasions, and what they all had in common was Unity.  They were practicing and pursuing religious ideals that were producing good results in the real world, and I thought to myself – Gotta get me some of that!

And so it began – this road that I am on.

As I learned about the teachings of Unity, I found ideas that worked, and ideas that made sense in everyday life. (Check the box for the Existential test).   I found ideas that made sense intellectually and intuitively. (Check the box for the Comparative test).  I found ideas that promoted wholeness and growth.  (Check the box for the Holistic Test).  I found ideas that were worthy of the faith of Jesus Christ.  (Check the box for the Christology test).

I knew I was building a life that worked base on the teachings and principles I was applying.  What I didn’t know is that I had a theological walk off home run!  Unity!  Practical Christianity!!  Pragmatic Enlightment!!!








Saturday, September 28, 2013

What is Ours To Do? Hospitality or Social Action?

What is Ours To Do?  Hospitality or Social Action?

Stretton Smith’s 4T Prosperity Program teaches participants about tithing 10% of their time, talent and treasure.  Regarding the time component, he uses a 40 hour work week as the basis for the calculation, and this results in a service opportunity or tithe of time that is equivalent to four hours a week.   As a former Volunteer Coordinator, I am aware of the many service opportunities in a typical church setting ranging from hospitality and ushering – and numerous other activities that directly served our own spiritual community – to serving breakfast once a month at a local homeless shelter – a service to our community at large.

Our Unity principles teach that it is not enough to know the truth; we must also live the truth.  Other Christian denominations have a similar viewpoint.  The website for the United Methodist Church http://www.umc.org speaks to a Theology of Discipleship and says that “We live out of our understanding of who we are in relationship to God, to one another, and to the world. . . As Christian disciples, we are not passive spectators but energetic participants in God’s activity in the world. . . Because of what God has done for us, we offer our lives back to God.  We order our lives in ways that embody Christ’s ministry in our families, workplaces, communities, and the world.”  The question that begs asking then is what exactly is an energetic participant in God’s activity supposed to be doing with their time and talent?

The UMC website goes on to talk about meeting specific needs such as hunger and illness, and it also speaks to embracing those who fall outside our natural social circle of family, friends and neighbors – people like prisoners, or people we may considers as enemies.  Beyond specific acts of love and charity to address specific needs, there is the broad umbrella of social justice.  Activism and advocacy in this context may address a broad range of issues including marriage equality, poverty reduction initiatives, or the creation of a Department of Peace.  Aside from the sheer number of issues and causes that may get lumped into this category, there seems to also be an underlying debate as to whether social justice is an organic outcome or by-product of collective human action, or a legislative construct externally imposed.     



Reza Aslan has written a book called “Zealot:  The Life and Times of Jesus of Nazareth” that looks at the social, economic, and political context in which Jesus existed and concludes that while Jesus was not a violent advocate of regime change, intellectually, he was squarely in the camp of the zealots who abhorred the Romans and the Temple inner circle.  It is Aslan’s position that Jesus was a political activist executed for the crime of sedition.

Considering then the life and times of Jesus, what is ours to do?  Is it sufficient to serve coffee after service and practice with the choir on Wednesday evenings?  Is it enough to rock babies born to crack addicted mothers at the local hospital and serve breakfast at the homeless shelter?  Must I show up at the Federal Building with my picket sign advocating Peace Now? 

Some would look at the range of choices – from serving coffee to camping out in the state legislature  - and say that it is all good.  And maybe it is – but if there is a theology of discipleship – What is ours to do?

Sunday, September 22, 2013

Theological Snapshot

My concept of and beliefs about God have changed significantly from when I was a student at Holy Innocents Catholic grade school to my time as a student here at Unity Institute.  My concept of God was patriarchal, judgmental and separate from me – somewhere out there in the galaxy.  When I prayed to him, I prefaced my request with “Lord, I am not worthy”.  In addition to the Apostle’s Creed, the Ten Commandments, the rosary and the litanies, I was taught that the only reason I might enter into the afterlife kingdom of heaven was by virtue of my baptism and the death and resurrection of God’s son, Jesus.  Baptism washed away the stain of original sin – Adam’s legacy to us.  The death and resurrection of Jesus the son was the ultimate reconciliation of the human race with God, the father.  That’s what I was taught, and that is what I accepted for a while, although I am not sure that I ever really, truly believed it.

It was a good story - some call it the greatest story ever told – but I could not and did not believe it.  My gut feeling, my hunch or hypothesis was that there was much more to God, to us, and to our relationship with God. I believed that there was a different explanation – something really amazing and inspiring – something that had no drama quotient in it whatsoever – something much bigger, much brighter, and much cleaner than this story of betrayal and suffering with markedly human overtones.  I believed that God’s story, while amazingly powerful, would turn out to be quite simple and straightforward, and I believed that it would be based on love and acceptance, not fear and punishment.

Today, my concept of God is that of a God energy or God intelligence – an evolutionary, creative dynamic, a vitality that is inherent in all life and matter at a cellular, molecular level.  God, as this energy or intelligence, is the source from which all things in the manifest universe are brought forward into a material condition. God, as this energy or intelligence is constantly expressing in, through and as everything that exists in the universe.
  
I believe in Jesus and his teachings, but do not believe that he is the son of God.  For me, Jesus is someone who developed his awareness of his inherent God energy or God intelligence to an extraordinarily high level.  He is the example, not the exception.  He demonstrated to us and for us the power that we each have within us.  His expression of the potential perfection that exists within each one of us makes him an example worth following.

I do not believe in the traditional Christian concept of the Holy Spirit or the Holy Trinity, but I do believe in the metaphysical concept of mind, idea and expression.  Regarding church and the need for or purpose of spiritual communities, I believe that there is great value in offering a variety of “on ramps” that provide people with access to opportunities to learn about, practice, and celebrate the transforming  power of truth principles and faith.